'One of These Things Is Not Like the Other': Likeness and Detrimental Impacts in US-Clove Cigarettes
Article from: TDM 5 (2012), in Legal Issues in Tobacco Control
Abstract
In this article, Todd Tucker critiques the Panel and Appellate Body decision, US-Measures Affecting the Production and Sale of Clove Cigarettes ('US-Clove Cigarettes'). The structure of Tucker's article is as follows: In Part 1, Tucker gives a background to the legislation that was challenged in US - Clove Cigarettes, namely, the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act ('FSPTCA'), the rationale for its differential treatment of menthol and clove cigarettes and what Tucker considers was a selective use of a likeness test by the Panel; in Part 2, Tucker argues that the Panel and ...