Content Join OGEMID
 
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • Rss

Transnational Dispute Management

Skip navigation

Transnational Dispute Management

The network for international arbitration, mediation and ADR, international investment law and Transnational Dispute Management

Join OGEMID

Transnational Dispute Management

The network for international arbitration, mediation and ADR, international investment law and Transnational Dispute Management

  • Sign in
  • Subscribe
  • Home
  • Sign in
  • About About
    1. Home
    2. About
    3. About TDM
    4. About TDM
    5. Founding Editor T.W. Wälde
    6. T.W. Wälde
    7. Editorial team
    8. Editorial team
    9. Contributing Authors
    10. Contributing Authors
    11. Subscriptions
    12. Subscriptions
  • Journal Journal
    1. Home
    2. Journal
    3. Browse Issues
    4. Browse
    5. Articles by Category
    6. By Category
    7. Articles by Author
    8. By Author
    9. Advance publication
    10. Advance publication
    11. Specials
    12. Specials
    13. Search
    14. Search
    15. Book reviews
    16. Reviews
  • Legal & Regulatory docs. L & r docs
    1. Home
    2. Legal & Regulatory docs.
    3. L&R by Country
    4. L&R by Country
    5. L&R by Category
    6. L&R by Category
    7. L&R recent additions
    8. L&R recent additions
    9. Search
    10. Search
  • Audiovisual library AV library
    1. Home
    2. Audiovisual library
    3. Audiovisual Library
    4. Audiovisual Library
    5. TDM/OGEMID Interviews
    6. TDM/OGEMID Interviews
    7. Conference presentations
    8. Conference presentations
  • OGEMID OGEMID
    1. Home
    2. OGEMID
    3. About OGEMID
    4. About OGEMID
    5. Suggest a topic
    6. Suggest a topic
    7. Guest programme
    8. Guest programme
    9. Seminar programme
    10. Seminar programme
    11. Browse archive
    12. Browse archive
    13. Search
    14. Search
    15. Join
    16. Join
  • News & Events Events
    1. Home
    2. News & Events
    3. News
    4. News
    5. Events
    6. Events
  • Subscribe
Home > Journal > Advance publication

Can Human Rights Counterclaims Succeed in Investment Treaty

  • Sign in
  • Suggested citation
M. Ng
M. Ng

Published 9 October 2018

Introduction

In investment treaty arbitration, at the forefront of adjudicators' minds is whether the host State's treatment of foreign investors falls short of the protection afforded by the investment treaties (BITs) in question, according to standards such as fair and equitable treatment and protection from unlawful expropriation. As such, host States' counterclaims on the basis of human rights have not hitherto played a significant role. In two decisions, Urbaser v Argentina and Burlington v Ecuador, the respective host States counterclaimed on the bases of human rights and environmental law, which introduced elements beyond the infringement of the investors' property rights - the primary consideration of investment tribunals. Furthermore, contrary to the view that counterclaims in investment arbitration always fail, Burlington demonstrated that this is not the case, and this is despite the well-established position of non-State actors such as multinational corporations (MNCs) not having enforceable human rights obligations under international law. Whilst Argentina's counterclaim in Urbaser was unsuccessful, the Tribunal's extensive discussion of human rights obligations of MNCs was a progressive departure from tribunals' reluctance to engage with human rights issues in the past. Additionally, it is encouraging that the Tribunal's reasoning has since been considered in the more recent decision of Bear Creek v Peru in the context of assessment of damages for contributory fault.

This paper argues that, so long as certain legal requirements are fulfilled, it is possible for host States to hold foreign investors to account for human rights violations in investment treaty arbitration. Specifically, in the absence of positive international human rights obligations on the part of MNCs, applicable laws in the host States covering aspects of human rights, such as environmental law and labour law, can assist host States in successfully pursuing counterclaims. Indeed, counterclaims are underutilised in investment arbitration; they can be a useful tool in balancing the asymmetry caused in part by responding States being always on the defence in investment disputes, and that tribunals ought not to shy away from proper consideration of human rights counterclaims where legal conditions allow.

Section I discusses the relevance of human rights in investment arbitration; section II analyses the legal framework of counterclaims in investment arbitration and the application of the key elements thereof in Burlington and Urbaser; section III discusses the tribunals' consideration of human rights in Urbaser and Bear Creek in the context of how previous tribunals have approached this issue; section IV discusses the difficulties highlighted by Urbaser with recommendations on how these challenges can be overcome, with a view of enabling human rights counterclaims in investment arbitration.

Footnotes omitted from this introduction.

To read this article you need to be a subscriber

Sign in

Forgot password?

Sign in

Subscribe

Fill in the registration form and answer a few simple questions to receive a quote.

Subscribe now

Suggested Citation

M. Ng (2018, forthcoming) "Can Human Rights Counterclaims Succeed in Investment Treaty"
(TDM, ISSN 1875-4120) October 2018, www.transnational-dispute-management.com

"Advance publication" is the name given to material that is published ahead of its appearance in a regular structured issue of our Journal. It is also possible to monitor this via RSS. Subscribers will receive update alerts via e-mail of the published articles as soon as they have been added to the website.

Other recently published material:

Impact Investment & Sustainable Development: Rethinking the Definition of Investment in African International Investment Agreements - An Outlier Perspective

17 February 2021

Relationship between the SADC Investment Agreement and National Investment Laws of SADC Member States: Perspectives from the Democratic Republic of Congo Investment Code

17 February 2021

International Arbitral Institutions Have Not Gone Far Enough in Issuing Reasoned Decisions on Adjudicated Administrative Matters

9 February 2021

Study of Damages Awards in Investor-State Cases

3 February 2021

Virtual Practice Makes Virtually Perfect – Practical Considerations for Virtual Hearings Identified through Simulations with Experienced Counsel and Arbitrators

26 January 2021

Complete listing of Advance publication.

Call for contributions

TDM Call for Papers: Old and New Disputes in Aerospace Law

Prof. Yun Zhao and Dr. J. Górski

  • Prof. ZHAO Yun
  • Dr. Jedrzej Gorski

TDM Call for Papers: The Future of Investment Law in Latin America

Dr. Sébastien Manciaux and Francisco Victoria-Andreu

  • Sebastien Manciaux
  • Francisco Victoria-Andreu

TDM Call for Papers: Islamic Finance and Dispute Resolution

Professor Dr A F M Maniruzzman

  • Professor Dr A F M Maniruzzman

Invitation to write: Overlap between Bankruptcy / Insolvency Proceedings and Arbitrations

TDM Editorial Team

Transnational Dispute Management

TDM Call for Papers: The African Continental Free Trade Agreement (AfCFTA)

J. Chaisse, J. Górski, E. Laryea, M.M. Mbengue, and K. Olaoye

  • Prof. Julien Chaisse
  • Dr. Jedrzej Gorski
  • Prof. Emmanuel Laryea
  • Prof. Makane Moïse Mbengue
  • Kehinde Olaoye

TDM Call for Papers: International Investment and Competition Law in AND with the Global South

Prof. Leila Choukroune and Anu Monga

  • Prof. Leila Choukroune
  • Anu Monga
  • More
  • Contribute

Stay connected

Sign up for our email alerts.

  • Issues
  • Advance publication
  • News
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • RSS

Join the debate

Want to join OGEMID, the leading on-line discussion platform for international dispute resolution?

Simply fill in the registration form to start your trial membership.

Download the app

  1. App store
  2. Google play

The Transnational Dispute Management Journal (TDM, ISSN 1875-4120) and OGEMID listserv focus on recent developments in the area of (investment) arbitration and dispute management, regulation, treaties, judicial and arbitral cases, voluntary guidelines, tax and contracting. Read our Terms & Conditions here, and our Privacy Policy here.

About TDM

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Contribute
  • Subscriptions
  • Contact
  • Help

Other publications

  • Oil, Gas & Energy Law Intelligence (OGEL)

© 2004 - 2021. Published by MARIS.

  • Home
  • Contribute
  • Subscriptions
  • Contact
  • Help