Content Join OGEMID
 
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • Rss

Transnational Dispute Management

Skip navigation

Transnational Dispute Management

The network for international arbitration, mediation and ADR, international investment law and Transnational Dispute Management

Join OGEMID

Transnational Dispute Management

The network for international arbitration, mediation and ADR, international investment law and Transnational Dispute Management

  • Sign in
  • Subscribe
  • Home
  • Sign in
  • About About
    1. Home
    2. About
    3. About TDM
    4. About TDM
    5. Founding Editor T.W. Wälde
    6. T.W. Wälde
    7. Editorial team
    8. Editorial team
    9. Contributing Authors
    10. Contributing Authors
    11. Subscriptions
    12. Subscriptions
  • Journal Journal
    1. Home
    2. Journal
    3. Browse Issues
    4. Browse
    5. Articles by Category
    6. By Category
    7. Articles by Author
    8. By Author
    9. Advance publication
    10. Advance publication
    11. Specials
    12. Specials
    13. Search
    14. Search
    15. Book reviews
    16. Reviews
  • Legal & Regulatory docs. L & r docs
    1. Home
    2. Legal & Regulatory docs.
    3. L&R by Country
    4. L&R by Country
    5. L&R by Category
    6. L&R by Category
    7. L&R recent additions
    8. L&R recent additions
    9. Search
    10. Search
  • Audiovisual library AV library
    1. Home
    2. Audiovisual library
    3. Audiovisual Library
    4. Audiovisual Library
    5. TDM/OGEMID Interviews
    6. TDM/OGEMID Interviews
    7. Conference presentations
    8. Conference presentations
  • OGEMID OGEMID
    1. Home
    2. OGEMID
    3. About OGEMID
    4. About OGEMID
    5. Suggest a topic
    6. Suggest a topic
    7. Guest programme
    8. Guest programme
    9. Seminar programme
    10. Seminar programme
    11. Browse archive
    12. Browse archive
    13. Search
    14. Search
    15. Join
    16. Join
  • News & Events Events
    1. Home
    2. News & Events
    3. News
    4. News
    5. Events
    6. Events
  • Subscribe
Home > Legal & Regulatory docs.

Bacilio Amorrortu USA v The Republic of Peru - PCA Case No 2020-11 - Partial Award on Jurisdiction - 05 August 2022

  • Sign in to download document
Country
  • Peru
  • United States
Year

2022

Summary

Partial Award on Jurisdiction

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION
The Parties
The Dispute
Background

PROCEDURAL HISTORY
Commencement of the Arbitration
Constitution of the Tribunal
Adoption of the Terms of Appointment and Procedural Order No. 1 (Rules of Procedure)
Memorial
Request for Disclosure of Funding Agreement (Procedural Order No. 2)
Decision on Bifurcation (Procedural Order No. 3)
Written Submissions on Preliminary Objections
Non-Disputing Party Submission
Hearing on Preliminary Objections (Procedural Order No. 4)
Post-Hearing Matters
Requests for Relief

OBJECTION UNDER ARTICLE 10.20.4 OF THE TREATY (OBJECTION 1)
Summary of Factual Allegations Relevant to Objection 1
The Respondent's Position
1. Preconditions for a Direct Negotiation as a Matter of Peruvian Law
2. Whether a Direct Negotiation was Ever Commenced
3. Right to a Contract
4. Protection of Expectations
5. Whether Declaratory Relief is an Available Remedy Under the USPTPA
The Claimant's Position
1. Preconditions for a Direct Negotiation as a Matter of Peruvian Law
2. Whether a Direct Negotiation was Ever Commenced
3. Right to a Contract
4. Protection of Expectations
5. Whether Declaratory Relief is an Available Remedy Under the USPTPA

THE TRIBUNAL'S ANALYSIS OF OBJECTION 1
1. The Direct Negotiation Procedure
2. The Legal Experts are Agreed that the Direct Negotiation Procedure is Started by
An Applicant's "Letter of Interest"
3. The Respondent's Expert, Mr. Vizquerra, Acknowledged that After Receipt of a "Letter of Interest" the Direct Negotiation Procedure 8 Obliged PeruPetro to Take a Number of Administrative Steps
4. In the Circumstances, the Respondent's Argument that PeruPetro Never Issued a "Qualification Certificate" to Mr. Amorrortu or Baspetrol Would Not Prevent an Award in the Claimant's Favor
5. The Respondent Contends that PeruPetro's President, Mr. Ortigas, Did Not Have the Authority to Give the Instructions Alleged by Mr. Amorrortu
6. The Respondent Contends that Direct Negotiations Never Actually Began
7. The Respondent Contends that the Facts Alleged by Mr. Amorrortu Concerning the International Public Tender, Even if Established, Do Not Constitute a Claim for Which an Award in his Favor May be Made Under USPTPA Article 10.26
8. Conclusion with Respect to the Respondent's Application Under Article 10.26.4 of the USPTPA

OBJECTION UNDER ARTICLE 10.18.2 OF THE TREATY (OBJECTION 4)
The Respondent's Position
1. Formal Requirements
2. Substantive Requirements
3. Whether the Waiver May Be Cured
4. Estoppel
The Claimant's Position
1. Formal Requirements
2. Substantive Requirements
3. Whether the Waiver May Be Cured
4. Estoppel
The Position of the United States of America

THE TRIBUNAL'S ANALYSIS OF OBJECTION 4 BASED ON NON-COMPLIANCE WITH ARTICLE 10.18.2

The Formal and Substantive Requirements for a Valid Waiver
Has the Claimant Provided a Valid Waiver?
Decision of the Tribunal Majority Professor Bernard Hanotiau and Mr. Toby Landau, Q.C.
Upholding the Respondent's Objection 4 Based on the Claimant's Invalid Waiver
Dissenting Opinion of the Honourable Ian Binnie, C.C., Q.C., on Objection 4

DECISION

...

THE DISPUTE

5. The dispute concerns the Respondent's alleged frustration of the Claimant's legitimate expectations to obtain a contract to perform oil drilling and extraction operations in oil Blocks III and IV of the Talara Basin, in the Province of Talara, Piura Region, Peru. In particular, the Claimant asserts that Peru ignored the rights he acquired directly to negotiate the contracts for Blocks III and IV ("Direct Negotiation(s)), and instead initiated a "rigged" public bidding process to favor another company, Graña y Montero S.A.A. ("Graña y Montero"), based on corrupt motives

6. The Claimant claims that, through this conduct, the Respondent violated its fair and equitable treatment ("FET") obligations under the United States-Peru Trade Promotion Agreement, ratified by Peru in June 2006, signed by the United States on December 14, 2007 and entered into force on February 1, 2009 (the "USPTPA" or the "Treaty").

7. The Respondent has advanced one objection under Article 10.20.4 of the Treaty and five jurisdictional objections under Article 23(3) of the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as revised in 2013 (the "UNCITRAL Rules").2 By its Decision on Bifurcation, dated January 21, 2021 (the "Decision on Bifurcation") the Tribunal ordered the bifurcation of the proceedings, such that two of those objections would be decided as preliminary questions: (i) the Respondent's objection under Article 10.20.4 of the Treaty ("Objection 1"); and (ii) the Respondent's objection that Mr. Amorrortu did not submit a valid waiver as required under Article 10.18.2(b) of the Treaty ("Objection 4").3 In this Partial Award, the Tribunal decides Objections 1 and 4 (together, the "Preliminary Objections").

8. For the reasons that follow, Objection 1 is dismissed but, by majority of the Tribunal, Objection 4 is upheld and the claim is dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

....

DECISION

289. For the reasons outlined above, the Tribunal by majority:

(i) finds that the Claimant has failed to comply with the requirement of Article 10.18.2(b) of the USPTPA by not providing a compliant waiver within the deadline specified in Article 10.16.4 of the USPTPA;

(ii) finds that the Claimant has failed to establish the requirements for the Respondent's consent to arbitrate under the USPTPA;

(iii) rejects the Claimant's request for leave to amend his Notice of Arbitration in order to attempt to cure his defective waiver;

(iv) dismisses the Claimant's claims for lack of jurisdiction; and

(v) reserves the issue of costs pending receipt of the submissions from the Parties, after which the Tribunal will render a Final Award.

...

Footnotes omitted.

To download this document you need to be a subscriber

Sign in

Forgot password?

Sign in

Subscribe

Fill in the registration form and answer a few simple questions to receive a quote.

Subscribe now

Documents missing? Documents to share? Let us know!

If you know of documents which are currently missing from our Legal & Regulatory database do let us know. You can send them directly to us for inclusion in the database, anonymously or otherwise.
Learn more here

Call for contributions

TDM Call for Papers: Sanctions and International Arbitration: Impact on Substantive and Procedural Issues

Ali Burney, Rinat Gareev, Kiran Nasir Gore, Dini Sejko, Prof. Joel Slawotsky, May Tai

  • Ali Burney
  • Rinat Gareev
  • Kiran Gore
  • Dr Dini Sejko
  • Prof. Joel Slawotsky
  • May Tai

TDM Call for Papers: National Courts as a Forum for the Resolution of Disputes under Article 26 Energy Charter Treaty

John P. Gaffney, Dr. iur Richard Happ,
Lucia Raimanova, Anna-Maria Tamminen, Dr. Catharine Titi

  • John P. Gaffney
  • Dr. iur Ricard Happ
  • Lucia Raimanova
  • Anna-Maria Tamminen
  • Dr. Catharine Titi

TDM Call for Papers: International Investment Arbitration - Environmental Protection and Climate Change Issues

Professor Dr A F M Maniruzzaman, Wendy J. Miles QC, Carla Lewis, Dr Stephen Minas

  • Professor Dr A F M Maniruzzaman
  • Wendy J. Miles QC
  • Carla Lewis
  • Dr Stephen Minas

TDM Call for Papers: The African Continental Free Trade Agreement (AfCFTA)

J. Chaisse, J. Górski, E. Laryea, M.M. Mbengue, and K. Olaoye

  • Prof. Julien Chaisse
  • Dr. Jedrzej Gorski
  • Prof. Emmanuel Laryea
  • Prof. Makane Moïse Mbengue
  • Kehinde Olaoye
  • More
  • Contribute

Advance publication

Summary of Young-OGEMID Hot Topic Discussion No. 2: "Empirical Study - Provisional Measures in Investor-State Arbitration" (February 2023)

24 Aug 2023

R. Kaur Bali

  • R. Kaur Bali

Counterclaims based on Corporate Climate Change Responsibility: Challenges and Prospects

22 Aug 2023

T. Ishikawa

  • T. Ishikawa

Simplifying the Pathway to 2030: The Need for More, not Less, Protection for Climate Change-Related investment

21 Aug 2023

R. Fowler, M.C.N.C.G. Putra

  • R. Fowler
  • M.C.N.C.G. Putra
  • More
  • Contribute

Stay connected

Sign up for our email alerts.

  • Issues
  • Advance publication
  • News
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
  • RSS

Join the debate

Want to join OGEMID, the leading on-line discussion platform for international dispute resolution?

Simply fill in the registration form to start your trial membership.

Download the app

  1. App store
  2. Google play

The Transnational Dispute Management Journal (TDM, ISSN 1875-4120) and OGEMID listserv focus on recent developments in the area of (investment) arbitration and dispute management, regulation, treaties, judicial and arbitral cases, voluntary guidelines, tax and contracting. Read our Terms & Conditions here, and our Privacy Policy here.

About TDM

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Contribute
  • Subscriptions
  • Contact
  • Help

Other publications

  • Oil, Gas & Energy Law Intelligence (OGEL)

© 2004 - 2023. Published by MARIS.

  • Home
  • Contribute
  • Subscriptions
  • Contact
  • Help